A contact extension and mixed success in IPO’s Bizet-inspired program

The Illinois Philharmonic Orchestra took the stage of Lincoln-Way North High School in Frankfort on Saturday for a Georges Bizet-centered program. Led by Stilian Kirov, the orchestra delivered solid performances that captured the artistry of Bizet at both ends of his composing career.
In remarks delivered by IPO executive director Christina Salerno before the concert, it was announced that the orchestra had extended the contract of the popular music director Kirov for three additional seasons through 2030. Conducting without a baton, Kirov used the flexibility of a choral-style approach to evoke nuanced orchestral textures and superb musical phrasing without sacrificing the firmness of his tempo direction.
Despite Kirov’s strong leadership, the concert got off to an unpolished start with Jessie Montgomery’s strings-only Starburst. Compared to the strong rhythmic cohesion the violins displayed later in the evening, in Montgomery’s work they simply sounded underrehearsed. The lack of cohesiom in the section was immediately apparent and gave a weak first impression of the orchestra.
The IPO proceeded with Bizet’s Symphony No. 1, a juvenile orchestral piece overshadowed by Bizet’s works for the stage. At its beginning, the symphony is stylistically a classical work, with Mozart-esque string ostinatos and a repetition of the lengthy introductory section (which the IPO mercifully skipped). However, as the piece progresses Bizet’s operatic tendencies emerge in the form of gorgeous aria-like melodies passed between wind soloists and the violin section.
Principal oboist Naomi Bensdorf Frisch was fantastic in her first- and second-movement solos, playing with flowing expression and projecting with ease in the hall. Likewise, each of the string sections excelled in following Kirov’s musical direction and creating moving musical lines.
In many ways, the challenging acoustic of Lincoln-Way North’s stage aided the performance. The front curtains, which were constantly blocking the upper fifth of the space, killed the volume of the cylindrical brass instruments without impeding their tone, allowing them to be present in tutti moments without overpowering the orchestral blend. However, this dampening effect seemed to cause issues for the rear-facing horns, who sometimes struggled to be heard. (Principal horn Lee Shirer was shaky on exposed entrances).
After intermission, the orchestra performed Rodion Shchedrin’s Carmen Suite, a recomposition of Bizet’s famed opera. Unlike the various Carmen orchestral suites which are mostly faithful to Bizet’s original work, Shchedrin’s Suite completely changes the instrumentation of Carmen to a string orchestra with four percussionists. While traces of the original instrumentation can still be found in the castanet rhythms and iconic cello line from the “Habañera,” Shchedrin’s work is distinctly his own and completely re-contextualizes the opera.
Kirov led the orchestra in a fine performance of the piece which highlighted the ensemble’s musical strengths but also the shortcomings of the suite as an interpretation of Carmen. While the string sections were once again outstanding in their melodic interpretations of lines originally written for vocalists, the orchestra could never escape the feeling of uncanniness that came from hearing familiar melodies changed so drastically. Shchedrin’s creative liberties were sometimes charming, such as in the fifth movement where he scored the habañera for a vibraphone-led percussion section and gave it a captivating bossa nova flare. But these moments were sparse and short; overall, the weirdness of the writing likely left some in the audience wishing to hear the original music.
As an encore, Kirov invited the winds back on stage for a performance of the Prelude to Act I of Bizet’s opera. Although the tempo was far from blistering, the joyous energy of the curtain-raiser to Carmen was a satisfying conclusion after Shchedrin’s awkward reinterpretation of the work. Although there were some hiccups, the Illinois Philharmonic nevertheless delivered a successful concert that showcased Bizet’s strengths as a composer, as well as Shchedrin’s weakness as an arranger.
The Illinois Philharmonic Orchestra performs Handel’s Messiah 2 p.m. December 12. ipomusic.org
Posted in Performances






